BYBLACK DUCK

IRC vs Jabber Chat Groups

Someone joined our spanking new IRC channel last night (#ohloh on irc.freenode.net) and alerted me to jabber chat groups. They offer similar functionality to IRC: you can reserve a ‘well-known group name’ (for example: ohloh@conference.jabber.org) and offers basic moderator controls.

The benefit, to me at least, is that this integrates much better with IM clients. Not that I mind IRC that much, but I’ve got to admit that I don’t enjoy the esoteric commands and bots very much.

In any case, we’ll officially stick with IRC for now – it’s way more popular. Secretly, I’ll keep rooting for jabber chat groups to take off.

  • http://ianp.org/ ianp (ianp)

    +1 for Jabber.

  • http://schlitt.info/opensource/ tobyS (Tobias Schlitt)

    +1 for IRC. I even use Bitlbee to map my IM connections to my IRC client. In general I have the feeling that IRC is more etsablished and accepted in the OS world. Just my .02.

  • VxJasonxV (Jason)

    You can always get a Jabber room and drop in a relay to bridge the two.

  • http://paul.elms.pro vyazovoi (Paul Elms)

    +1 for jabber

  • http://dscoder.com Catfish_Man (David Smith)

    There’s a summer of code project on the XSF idea list to make irc channels transparently bridgeable to jabber rooms. Seems like it would solve this nicely :)

    (there are existing solutions, as Jason mentioned, but my understanding is that they’re a little clunky. I could very well be wrong though, worth checking out!)

  • http://valessiobrito.info valessio (Valessio S Brito)
  • mariajim (mariajim)

    There’s a summer of code scheme on the XSF idea list to make IRC channels clearly bridgeable to Witter rooms. Seems like it would solve this satisfactorily:
    Thanks
    Maria Jim
    Bomber Leather Jackets Manufacturers